American League
1980: George Brett
1981: Rollie Fingers
1982: Robin Yount
1983: Cal Ripken Jr.
1984: Willie Hernández
1985: Don Mattingly
1986: Roger Clemens
1987: George Bell
1988: Jose Canseco
1989: Robin Yount
1990: Rickey Henderson
1991: Cal Ripken Jr.
1992: Dennis Eckersley
1993: Frank Thomas
1994: Frank Thomas
1995: Mo Vaughn
1996: Juan González
1997: Ken Griffey Jr.
1998: Juan González
1999: Iván Rodríguez
National League
1980: Mike Schmidt
1981: Mike Schmidt
1982: Dale Murphy
1983: Dale Murphy
1984: Ryne Sandberg
1985: Willie McGee
1986: Mike Schmidt
1987: Andre Dawson
1988: Kirk Gibson
1989: Kevin Mitchell
1990: Barry Bonds
1991: Terry Pendleton
1992: Barry Bonds
1993: Barry Bonds
1994: Jeff Bagwell
1995: Barry Larkin
1996: Ken Caminiti
1997: Larry Walker
1998: Sammy Sosa
1999: Chipper Jones
