American League
1960: Roger Maris
1961: Roger Maris
1962: Mickey Mantle
1963: Elston Howard
1964: Brooks Robinson
1965: Zoilo Versalles
1966: Frank Robinson
1967: Carl Yastrzemski
1968: Denny McLain
1969: Harmon Killebrew
1970: Boog Powell
1971: Vide Blue
1972: Dick Allen
1973: Reggie Jackson
1974: Jeff Burroughs
1975: Fred Lynn
1976: Thurman Munson
1977: Rod Carew
1978: Jim Rice
1979: Don Baylor
National League
1960: Dick Groat
1961: Frank Robinson
1962: Maury Wills
1963: Sandy Koufax
1964: Ken Boyer
1965: Willie Mays
1966: Roberto Clemente
1967: Orlando Cepeda
1968: Bob Gibson
1969: Willie McCovey
1970: Johnny Bench
1971: Joe Torre
1972: Johnny Bench
1973: Pete Rose
1974: Steve Garvey
1975: Joe Morgan
1976: Joe Morgan
1977: George Foster
1978: Dave Parker
1979: Keith Hernandez / Willie Stargell